Syllabus

Course Goals Readings & Videos Course Requirements Schedule of Assignments

Course Goals

  • To respond imaginatively to problems of the human experience in the face of technological and social change

  • To evaluate the differences created by distinctions of genre and form in textual presentation

  • To see texts in relation to their changing historical and intellectual contexts

  • To examine critically the historical development of human responses to the concept of limits

  • To develop critical skills for writing and speaking about literature

  • To develop and refine skills appropriate to college writing

  • To develop an active, rather than passive, understanding of the literary works, through discussion, writing, and personal exploration

Readings and Videos

Frankenstein and the Limits of Technological Creation

  • Mary Shelley, Frankenstein

  • Video: Stanley Kubrick, 2001: A Space Odyssey (excerpts)

Utopia and the Limits of Social Progress

  • Thomas More, Utopia 

  • George Orwell, 1984

  • Marge Piercey, Woman on the Edge of Time

  • Video: Fred Wilcox, Forbidden Planet

First Contact:  the Limits of Human Knowledge

  • Arthur C. Clarke, Rendezvous with Rama

  • Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle, The Mote in God's Eye

  • Video: Robert Wise, The Day the Earth Stood Still

 

Artist's Rendering of "Genghis" Robot for Mars Exploration--NASA Image Gallery

 

Artist's rendering of "Odyssey" probe detecting ice on Mars--NASA Image Gallery

 

Course Requirements

Forum 20%
Major Project 20%
Critical Paper #1 20%
Critical Paper #2 20%
Quizzes 10%
Class Participation 10%

Forum: Students will participate in the class online discussion group, the Forum. Discussion questions will be posted on a regular basis. Each student will be expected to contribute the equivalent of a page and a half (about 300 words) per week; this minimum length requirement may be satisfied by a single long contribution, or by several short ones (as part of the ongoing discussion). Contributions to the Forum will be evaluated at mid-term and at the end of the semester.

Quizzes:  There will be periodic quizzes on the works being studied. Each quiz will consist of approximately five short answer questions.

Major Project: Students will produce a major individual or group project, designed to elaborate or extend the themes of the course. Work on the projects will extend over most of the semester. The structure of the projects will be individually determined, but projects might include world-building simulations, radio plays, video productions, theatrical montages from course readings, website presentations, or traditional research papers. Each project will include an oral defense and a response to an evaluation rubric.  For more information on the major project, see the Major Projects page

Critical Papers: There will be two 5-6 page (1500-2000 word) critical analyses of works studied during the course. The papers should be typed (or word-processed) and double-spaced. 

Class Participation: Class participation is essential to the success of the course. Students will be evaluated on both the quantity and the quality of their participation on a day-to-day basis. Participation may alter the final course grade by up to 10 points on a 100 point scale.

Attendance: Any absence in excess of three may result in a lowered final grade.

Student evaluation of course: Students will complete online course evaluations in the final week of the semester.

Academic honesty: All students will be expected to be familiar with the Edgewood College Academic Honesty Policy, and to abide by it in all course work.  The Academic Honesty Policy may be found on the course website and in the Edgewood College Student Handbook.  Plagiarism will be discussed in class, but class discussion should not be considered a substitute for reading and understanding the full college policy.

Students with disabilities It is “the policy of the College to ensure that no person shall, solely by reason of disability, be excluded from participation in, or be denied the benefits of, any program or activity operated by Edgewood College.”  If you have a disability and you have documented accommodations for the disability through the Disabilities Services Coordinator, and if you need to use those accommodations for this class, please notify the professor as soon as possible.  If you have questions about accommodations, contact Elizabeth Watson in the Student Resource Center (663-2281).  She will work with you on appropriate accommodations, and all information will be kept confidential.

Assessment of Student Work

Papers:  Papers will be graded on the standard letter-grade scale (A, AB, B, BC, C, CD, D, F).  Due dates are listed in the Schedule of Assignments.  Papers will be graded according to the following criteria:

Demonstration of an understanding of the text beyond the level of plot

A clearly stated and critically perceptive thesis

Extensive and appropriate use of the text to support the thesis

Careful organization of ideas and careful reasoning

Effective incorporation of quotation, paraphrase, and other supporting evidence

Coherent connection of ideas and effective transitions

Effective variation of sentence patterns and lengths

Precise and appropriate word choice

Effective use of standard English grammar and syntax and careful proofreading

Quizzes:  Each quiz will include 5 short-answer questions.  Each question will ask the student to identify a detail, character, event, etc. from one of the works assigned for the class.  Each correct answer will be worth one point. 

Forum:  Each student must post on a regular basis on the Forum.  The Forum is intended to establish a dialogue about the course materials and to give students an opportunity to "think out loud" about them.  Forum postings will be evaluated twice during the semester, and given a plus, check, or minus.  A check gives credit for the assignment, but does not affect the final semester average.  A minus will be averaged in at one letter grade lower than the student's average for other work.  A plus will be averaged in at one letter grade higher than the student's average for other work.  Forum postings will be evaluated according to the following criteria:

At the time of evaluation, each student must have posted an average of at least 300 words per week.

All postings must be concerned with the material covered by the class.

Postings should deal specifically with textual materials related to the class, quoting or making specific references to details whenever appropriate.

Postings should strive to get beyond the superficial or obvious; comments or discussion which lead to new critical insights will be given highest value.

Grammar, mechanics, etc. will not be included in the evaluation of Forum postings

Class Participation:  Class participation will be evaluated on a daily basis.  Participation will be evaluated on the relevance and quality of contributions, as well as their quantity.   Participation in general class discussions, question-and-answer sessions, small group work, and all other class activities will be included in the evaluation. 

Major Project: Students will produce a major individual or group project, designed to elaborate or extend the themes of the course. Work on the projects will extend over most of the semester. The structure of the projects will be individually determined, but projects might include world-building simulations, radio plays, video productions, theatrical montages from course readings, website presentations, or traditional research papers. Each project will include an oral defense and a response to an evaluation rubric. Evaluation criteria for each project will be negotiated individually prior to the beginning of the project.

 

 


Schedule of Assignments

W 08/29 Course intro: science fiction and the concept of human limits Read:  Frankenstein and the Limits of Technological Creation:  Introductory Reading.  Begin reading Frankenstein
M 9/3 LABOR DAY Begin posting on Forum
W 9/5 Background: Mary Shelley and the Frankenstein motif  
M 9/10 Frankenstein Quiz on Frankenstein
W 9/12 Frankenstein  
M 9/17 Frankenstein Begin reading Utopia
W 09/19 The Frankenstein motif in modern popular culture  
M 9/24 Background:  Plato, Sir Thomas More, and the Tradition of the Literary Utopia  
W 9/26 More's Utopia Quiz on Utopia
M 10/1 More's Utopia Begin reading 1984
W 10/3 The modern dystopia: George Orwell's 1984  
M 10/8 Orwell's 1984  Quiz on 1984
W 10/10 Orwell's 1984 Begin reading Woman on the Edge of Time
M 10/15 FALL BREAK  
W 10/17 Piercey's Woman on the Edge of Time Quiz on Woman on the Edge of Time
M 10/22 Piercey's Woman on the Edge of Time First critical paper due
W 10/24 Piercey's Woman on the Edge of Time Begin reading Rendezvous with Rama
M 10/29 The problem of the "other": First contact and the limits of knowledge  
W 10/31 Clarke's Rendezvous with Rama Quiz on Rendezvous with Rama
M 11/5 Clarke's Rendezvous with Rama  
W/11/7 Clarke's Rendezvous with Rama Begin reading The Mote in God's Eye
M 11/12 Niven and Pournelle's The Mote in God's Eye Quiz on The Mote in God's Eye
W 11/14 Niven and Pournelle's The Mote in God's Eye  
M 11/19 Niven and Pournelle's The Mote in God's Eye  
W 11/21 Synthesis: The Limits of Human Experience  
M 11/26 Major Projects  
W 11/28 Major Projects  
M 12/3 Major Projects  
W 12/5 Major Projects  
M 12/10 Major Projects  
W 12/12 Presentations and discussion  
Final exam day Presentations and discussion  
 

 

 

Page background image credit:  Landslides on Callisto, NASA (Planetary Photjournal)

 

This page developed and maintained by James Hunter
Edgewood College, Madison, WI
Comments and suggestions: hunter@edgewood.edu
Last updated: 09/11/2007

Image credits for top banner:  
Left panel:  Lunar Excursion Module Simulator, NASA (Langley)
Right panel:  3-D Protein Structure, U.S. Department of Energy Human Genome Program, http://www.ornl.gov/hgmis

Middle panel background:  Blurred version of portion of Wired Cell, U.S. Department of Energy Genomes to Life Program, http://doegenomestolife.org